“The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County” aired Nov. 12 on Hulu, and its name does not fit the plot. Not all of the cast members are members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and several do not associate with or participate in the religion at all.
For example, “Mormon wife” Bobbi Althoff said that she was never a part of the church but has a brother who is. Avery Woods and Aspyn Ovard stated that they grew up around a heavily Latter-day Saints population. That means three of the main nine cast members have never been members of the church.
This doesn’t account for the fact that other castmates are not exactly active in the religion, even though they may have been raised that way or identify as part of it. This seems like a marketing scheme to continue to use the same show title as the previous seasons, which took place in Utah and gained fame and controversy.
The difference between Utah and California is that around 50% of Utah adults identify as church members compared to only 1% of California adults. Living in Utah can mean encountering social expectations even if you are not a member, which might include things like getting married young, not drinking alcohol and waiting for marriage.
Another portion of the title has little to do with the actual cast. Three of the nine cast members are divorced or are currently getting a divorce, even though the show title includes the label of “wife.” This discrepancy seems like a ploy to either make the franchise similar to “The Real Housewives” or to relate to traditional family structures that align with being part of the church.
The only two things all nine women seem to have in common are being a mom and an influencer of some kind. They could have easily used either of those identities and created a new reality TV show about how influencers interact in Orange County, but they chose to make it part of this specific brand.
Unfortunately, this cast and the previous cast have had their fair share of controversies that are now associated with the church. There have been several toxic relationships and addictions featured during episodes, and some cast members have received severe online backlash for comments they have made in the past.
As someone who grew up as a member of this church, I find it incredibly frustrating that this cast is pretending that they identify this way. Their bad decisions and chaotic tactics to get views reflect badly on an entire religion.
The issue is not that people have to act perfectly in order to showcase the church in a good light, but that the show packages the insane scandals as part of being a member of the church. Clearly, most people are aware that things are dramatized for reality TV, but I find it interesting how comfortable networks are with disregarding respect for a religious group.
I question whether or not they would be more respectful of how they are portraying a church if it wasn’t The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. There is a difference between telling stories about women in the church and using the church to sell stories that have little to do with religion.


































































































































